Contact Us

Use the form on the right to contact us.

You can edit the text in this area, and change where the contact form on the right submits to, by entering edit mode using the modes on the bottom right. 

317 West Sixth Street
Erie, PA 16507

(814) 453-6921

The Preferred Restaurants® of Erie & Chautauqua is a collection of exceptional dining establishments that participate in a limited membership, top-tier dinner club that enables a select clientele to experience their exceptional food and ambiance at great savings.

Nic-l-Inn Restaurant


12045 Bone Run Road
Frewsburg, New York 14738

During Season Serving Dinner
Tuesday thru Saturday from 5 pm; Sunday 1 to 8 pm.

Closed Mondays.

Call for Winter Hours.



Chef’s Signature Cajun Seafood Bisque

French Onion Soup

Scallops Au Gratin

Stuffed Hot Peppers

Nicolino Bread


Prime Rib


Homemade Lasagna

Strip & Scampi

Veal Piccata

Day Boat Scallops

Stuffed Cod


Éclair Sundae






Country Hospitality

Experience southern hospitality and exceptional dining in the magnificent countryside. Encounter breathtaking views of the Allegheny Mountain foothills and the ever changing ‘four seasons’ on your drive to this serene setting at the Nic-L-Inn. Owners Deborah Walston and Jack Kraatz continue the 35+ years of traditions and recipes that have made Nic-L-Inn ‘the’ restaurant to celebrate milestone events or enjoy a relaxed dining experience.

Begin your evening with an appetizer – the Scallops au Gratin has a wonderfully unique flavor and the Stuffed Hot Peppers are the restaurant’s own recipe. Delicious Prime Rib, Nicolino Bread and Chef’s Signature Cajun Seafood Bisque are specialties known throughout the region. They are simply not to be missed! Choose from other entrée favorites such as Cod with Seafood Stuffing or Homemade Lasagna. (Italian doesn’t get any better than this!) For the perfect finale, try the Éclair Sundae – a flaky pastry shell filled with golden vanilla ice cream and covered with chocolate sauce and mounds of whipped cream. The three flagstone fireplaces and country charm are sure to enhance your dining pleasure!

Reservations are recommended.

Directions: From I-90, take I-86 east, to Exit 14 (Kennedy/Warren). Turn Left onto US-62. Continue on US-62; turn left on CR-36. Nic-L-Inn is about 6 miles ahead on the right.